Qingquan Fan;Xingyu Wang;Yinan Liu;Jing Cao;

• 1:School of Public Finance and Taxation
• 2: Capital University of Economics and Business
• 3:National Institute of Metrology

Abstract：

Joint innovation is an important measure for China to break down technological barriers and achieve technological breakthroughs in key areas. Against the background of increasing pressure on China's fiscal balance, it is of great practical significance to objectively assess the impact of government R&D subsidies on corporate collaborative innovation. Taking Chinese A-share listed companies from 2007 to 2022 as a sample, based on the invention patent data, this paper identifies the joint innovation behaviours of enterprises, and examines the impact of government R&D subsidies on corporate joint innovation. It is found that government R&D subsidies have a facilitating effect on corporate joint innovation. Further analyses show that co-innovation promotion is more pronounced for firms with high R&D risks, and that the type of subsidy with high signal strength promotes joint innovation more significantly. The above findings provide a scientific basis for optimizing the structure of R&D subsidies and accelerating the establishment of joint innovation networks in China.

Key Words：

Abstract:

Keywords:

Foundation: 国家社会科学基金项目“创新联合体建设背景下财政支持政策协同效应及优化策略研究”（项目编号：24BJY045）的资助

Authors: Qingquan Fan;Xingyu Wang;Yinan Liu;Jing Cao;

References：

• 白俊红，吕晓红.2014.自主研发、协同创新与外资引进——来自中国地区工业企业的经验证据[J].财贸经济，35(11):89-100.Bai J H,Lv X H.2014.Independent R&D,cooperative innovation and foreign investment introduction[J].Finance & Trade Economics,35(11):89-100.(in Chinese) 白俊红，蒋伏心.2015.协同创新、空间关联与区域创新绩效[J].经济研究，50(7):174-187.Bai J H,Jiang F X.2015.Synergy innovation,spatial correlation and regional innovation performance[J].Economic Research Journal,50(7):174-187.(in Chinese) 陈红，纳超洪，雨田木子，等.2018.内部控制与研发补贴绩效研究[J].管理世界，34(12):149-164.Chen H,Na C H,Yutian M Z,et al.2018.Internal control and R&D subsidy performance[J].Journal of Management World,34(12):149-164.(in Chinese) 陈劲，阳银娟.2012.协同创新的理论基础与内涵[J].科学学研究，30(2):161-164.Chen J,Yang Y J.2012.Theoretical basis and content for collaborative innovation[J].Studies in Science of Science,30(2):161-164.(in Chinese) 方先明，胡丁.2023.企业ESG表现与创新——来自A股上市公司的证据[J].经济研究，58(2):91-106.Fang X M,Hu D.2023.Corporate ESG performance and innovation:Empirical evidence from A-share listed companies[J].Economic Research Journal,58(2):91-106.(in Chinese) 何晴，刘净然，范庆泉.2022.企业研发风险与补贴政策优化研究[J].经济研究，57(5):192-208.He Q,Liu J R,Fan Q Q.2022.A study on firms' R&D risks and subsidy policy optimization[J].Economic Research Journal,57(5):192-208.(in Chinese) 李俊青，张雪莹，袁博.2023.社会网络异质性与人力资本误配[J].经济研究，58(12):167-184.Li J Q,Zhang X Y,Yuan B.2023.Heterogeneity of social networks and mismatch of human capital[J].Economic Research Journal,58(12):167-184.(in Chinese) 李蕾，刘荣增.2022.产业融合与制造业高质量发展：基于协同创新的中介效应[J].经济经纬，39(2):78-87.Li L,Liu R Z.2022.Industrial integration and high-quality development of manufacturing industry:Based on intermediary effect of collaborative innovation[J].Economic Survey,39(2):78-87.(in Chinese) 李祖超，梁春晓.2012.协同创新运行机制探析——基于高校创新主体的视角[J].中国高教研究，(7):81-84.Li Z C,Liang C X.Exploration on the cooperative innovation mechanism:Base on the perspective of university[J].China Higher Education Research,(7):81-84.(in Chinese) 刘丹，闫长乐.2013.协同创新网络结构与机理研究[J].管理世界，29(12):1-4.Liu D,Yan C L.2013.A study on the structure and machanism of the coordinate innovation network[J].Journal of Management World,29(12):1-4.(in Chinese) 刘净然，何晴.2023.企业研发风险、央地选择偏好与政府补贴政策优化研究[J].财政研究，(4):97-112.Liu J R,He Q.2023.Firms' R&D risks,governments' preferences and subsidy policy optimization[J].Public Finance Research,(4):97-112.(in Chinese) 刘志迎，单洁含.2013.技术距离、地理距离与大学-企业协同创新效应——基于联合专利数据的研究[J].科学学研究，31(9):1331-1337.Liu Z Y,Shan J H.2013.The impact of technological distance and geographical distance on university-industry collaborative innovation:An analysis of joint-patent[J].Studies in Science of Science,31(9):1331-1337.(in Chinese) 龙小宁，刘灵子，张靖.2023.企业合作研发模式对创新质量的影响——基于中国专利数据的实证研究[J].中国工业经济，(10):174-192.Long X N,Liu L Z,Zhang J.2023.Influence of corporate collaborative innovation patterns on innovation quality:An empirical analysis of Chinese patents[J].China Industrial Economics,(10):174-192.(in Chinese) 陆国庆，王舟，张春宇.2014.中国战略性新兴产业政府创新补贴的绩效研究[J].经济研究，49(7):44-55.Lu G Q,Wang Z,Zhang C Y.2014.Research on the performance of subsidizing innovation for Chinese strategic emerging industry[J].Economic Research Journal,49(7):44-55.(in Chinese) 涂振洲，顾新.2013.基于知识流动的产学研协同创新过程研究[J].科学学研究，31(9):1381-1390.Tu Z Z,Gu X.2013.Study on process of industry-university-research institute collaborative innovation based on knowledge flow[J].Studies in Science of Science,31(9):1381-1390.(in Chinese) 万筱雯，杨波.2023.企业跨国并购的协同创新效应[J].财经研究，49(12):34-47.Wan X W,Yang B.2023.The collaborative innovation effect of enterprise cross-border M&As[J].Journal of Finance and Economics,49(12):34-47.(in Chinese) 万幼清，王云云.2014.产业集群协同创新的企业竞合关系研究[J].管理世界，30(8):175-176.Wan Y Q,Wang Y Y.2014.A study on the relationship,in competition and cooperation,between firms of the industrial group[J].Journal of Management World,30(8):175-176.(in Chinese) 王岳龙，袁旺平.2023.地铁开通、协同合作与企业创新[J].经济评论(6):140-158.Wang Y L,Yuan W P.2023.Metro opening,collaboration and enterprise innovation[J].Economic Review,(6):140-158.(in Chinese) 吴贾，姚先国，张俊森.2015.城乡户籍歧视是否趋于止步——来自改革进程中的经验证据：1989—2011[J].经济研究，50(11):148-160.Wu J,Yao X G,Zhang J S.2015.Is hukou discrimination between urban and rural areas vanishing?Evidence from the reform period:1989—2011[J].Economic Research Journal,50(11):148-160.(in Chinese) 吴洁，车晓静，盛永祥，等.2019.基于三方演化博弈的政产学研协同创新机制研究[J].中国管理科学，27(1):162-173.Wu J,Che X J,Sheng Y X,et al.2019.Study on government-industry-university-institute collaborative innovation based on tripartite evolutionary game[J].Chinese Journal of Management Science,27(1):162-173.(in Chinese) 吴伟伟，张天一.2021.非研发补贴与研发补贴对新创企业创新产出的非对称影响研究[J].管理世界，37(3):137-160.Wu W W,Zhang T Y.2021.The asymmetric influence of non-R&D subsidies and R&D subsidies on innovation output of new ventures[J].Journal of Management World,37(3):137-160.(in Chinese) 夏丽娟，谢富纪，王海花.2017.制度邻近、技术邻近与产学协同创新绩效——基于产学联合专利数据的研究[J].科学学研究，35(5):782-791.Xia L J,Xie F J,Wang H H.2017.The impact of institutional proximity and technological proximity on industry-university collaborative innovation performance:An analysis of joint-patent data[J].Studies in Science of Science,35(5):782-791.(in Chinese) 解学梅.2013.协同创新效应运行机理研究：一个都市圈视角[J].科学学研究，31(12):1907-1920.Xie X M.2013.Operation mechanism of synergic innovative effect:A perspective from metropolitan region[J].Studies in Science of Science,31(12):1907-1920.(in Chinese) 解学梅，刘丝雨.2015.协同创新模式对协同效应与创新绩效的影响机理[J].管理科学，28(2):27-39.Xie X M,Liu S Y.2015.Impact mechanism of collaborative innovation modes on collaborative effect and innovation performance[J].Journal of Management Science,28(2):27-39.(in Chinese) 叶伟巍，梅亮，李文，等.2014.协同创新的动态机制与激励政策——基于复杂系统理论视角[J].管理世界，30(6):79-91.Ye W W,Mei L,Li W,et al.2014.The dynamic mechanism of the coordinated innovation,and the policy for the incentive mechanism:A study from the perspective of a complex system[J].Journal of Management World,30(6):79-91.(in Chinese) 叶阳平，马文聪.2023.政府补贴、高管团队社会资本与企业创新合作[J].科研管理，44(5):85-95.Ye Y P,Ma W C.2023.Government subsidies,top management team social capital,and innovation cooperation of enterprises[J].Science Research Management,44(5):85-95.(in Chinese) 张米尔，任腾飞，黄思婷.2024.中国企业海外市场遭遇专利战的实证研究：以美国市场为例[J].中国软科学，(3):37-46.Zhang M E,Ren T F,Huang S T.2024.Empirical study on Chinese enterprises encountering patent war in overseas markets:Evidence from the US market[J].China Soft Science,(3):37-46.(in Chinese) 章元，程郁，佘国满.2018.政府补贴能否促进高新技术企业的自主创新?——来自中关村的证据[J].金融研究，(10):123-140.Zhang Y,Cheng Y,She G M.2018.Can government subsidy improve high-tech firms' independent innovation?Evidence from Zhongguancun firm panel data[J].Journal of Financial Research,(10):123-140.(in Chinese) 周开国，卢允之，杨海生.2017.融资约束、创新能力与企业协同创新[J].经济研究，52(7):94-108.Zhou K G,Lu Y Z,Yang H S.2017.Financial constraints,innovative capability and firms' collaborative innovation[J].Economic Research Journal,52(7):94-108.(in Chinese) Ahuja G.2000.Collaboration networks,structural holes,and innovation:A longitudinal study[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,45(3):425-455. Bianchi M,Murtinu S,Scalera V G.2019.R&D subsidies as dual signals in technological collaborations[J].Research Policy,48(9):103821. Chapman G,Lucena A,Afcha S.2018.R&D subsidies & external collaborative breadth:Differential gains and the role of collaboration experience[J].Research Policy,47(3):623-636. Chen L M,Tao S Y,Xie X H,et al.2024.The evaluation of innovation efficiency and analysis of government subsidies influence—Evidence from China's metaverse listed companies[J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change,201:123213. Clausen T H.2009.Do subsidies have positive impacts on R&D and innovation activities at the firm level?[J].Structural Change and Economic Dynamics,20(4):239-253. Faems D,Van Looy B,Debackere K.2005.Interorganizational collaboration and innovation:Toward a portfolio approach[J].Journal of Product Innovation Management,22(3):238-250. Mulier K,Samarin I.2021.Sector heterogeneity and dynamic effects of innovation subsidies:Evidence from Horizon 2020[J].Research Policy,50(10):104346. Xu X F,Cui X D,Chen X Y,et al.2022.Impact of government subsidies on the innovation performance of the photovoltaic industry:Based on the moderating effect of carbon trading prices[J].Energy Policy,170:113216.
• (1)限于篇幅,描述性统计结果留存备索。